Is silver really a good alternative to gold?

Luis57

Luis57

New member
I'm really looking into alternative to gold, as it feel to be a little bit volatile lately. So, is silver a good choice?
 
Sort by date Sort by votes
Silver as a gold alternative is a different trade than people usually frame it. Gold is monetary, silver is 60% industrial, so the GC/SI ratio cycles with industrial demand and not with pure safe-haven flow. Historically the ratio ranges 50:1 to 90:1, and right now we're up near the high end. When the ratio compresses it's usually silver catching up fast (it's higher beta to gold in a rally, roughly 1.5x on a 90-day window) rather than gold underperforming. Which means if you want monetary-debasement protection, hold gold. If you want leveraged exposure to a gold rally plus some industrial-cycle exposure, use silver. They're not substitutes, they're different bets with partial overlap.
 
Upvote 0 Downvote
On the GC/SI ratio piece from my post above: for tracking the ratio and its correlation to industrial-demand proxies (copper, DXY, real yields) I keep a dashboard on https://covenantalpha.com with GC, SI, HG, and the DXY all plotted together on synchronized timeframes. Makes the industrial-vs-monetary split visible in a way that just watching each symbol separately doesn't. Useful when the ratio makes a 5+ point move in a week and you want to know whether it was the gold leg or the silver leg doing the work. Still use futures-specific platforms for the actual execution.
 
Upvote 0 Downvote
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top